The Phantom Menace: the F-4 in Air Combat in Vietnam Page: 2

                                
Hankins, Michael W. The Phantom Menace: The F-4 in Air Combat in Vietnam. Master
of Science (History), August 2013, 161 pp., 2 illustrations, bibliography, 84 titles.
The F-4 Phantom II was the United States' primary air superiority fighter aircraft during
the Vietnam War. This airplane epitomized American airpower doctrine during the early Cold
War, which diminished the role of air-to-air combat and the air superiority mission. As a result,
the F-4 struggled against the Soviet MiG fighters used by the North Vietnamese Air Force. By
the end of the Rolling Thunder bombing campaign in 1968, the Phantom traded kills with MiGs
at a nearly one-to-one ratio, the worst air combat performance in American history. The aircraft
also regularly failed to protect American bombing formations from MiG attacks. A bombing halt
from 1968 to 1972 provided a chance for American planners to evaluate their performance and
make changes. The Navy began training pilots specifically for air combat, creating the Navy
Fighter Weapons School known as "Top Gun" for this purpose. The Air Force instead focused on
technological innovation and upgrades to their equipment. The resumption of bombing and air
combat in the 1972 Linebacker campaigns proved that the Navy's training practices were
effective, while the Air Force's technology changes were not, with kill ratios becoming worse.
However, the last three months of the campaign introduced an American ground radar system
that proved more effective than Top Gun in improving air-to-air combat performance. By the end
of the Vietnam War, the Air Force and Navy overcame the inherent problems with the Phantom,
which were mostly of their own making.