Do Budget Deficits Push Up Interest Rates and Is This the Relevant Question? Page: 2 of 16
The following text was automatically extracted from the image on this page using optical character recognition software:
Do Budget Deficits Push Up Interest Rates
and Is This the Relevant Question?
With mounting budget deficits, attention has focused on their economic effect,
particularly whether or not budget deficits raise interest rates. Any explanation of the
budget deficit-interest rate relationship must first come to grips with an indisputable
fact: budget deficits consume real resources, and this - rather than the behavior of
interest rates - is the more relevant public policy concern. When the government
borrows from the public to finance public spending or tax cuts, the resources must
come from somewhere. In mainstream theory, the resources come from the nation's
pool of saving, which pushes up interest rates for simple supply and demand reasons.
This "crowds out" private investment which was competing with government
borrowing for the same pool of national saving. For this reason, economists often
describe deficits as placing a burden on future generations.
But other theories offer different explanations of where the resources come from
that do not involve higher interest rates. In the capital mobility view, foreigners lend
the United States the savings it needs to finance a deficit, leaving interest rates
unaffected. But as foreign capital comes to the country, the dollar must appreciate.
This causes U.S. exports and import-competing industries to become less competitive
and the trade deficit to expand. In an alternative theory, popularly known as the
Barro-Ricardo view, forward-looking, rational, infinitely-lived individuals see that
a budget deficit would result in higher taxes or lower government spending in the
future. Therefore, they reduce their consumption and save more today. This
provides the government with the saving needed to finance its deficit, placing no
upward pressure on interest rates. Empirical evidence that budget deficits do not
affect interest rates does not prove that government budget deficits do not impose a
burden, as demonstrated by the capital mobility and Barro-Ricardo views. In the
capital mobility view, deficits crowd out the trade sector of the economy; in the
Barro-Ricardo view, they crowd out current private consumption. And in both of
these views, deficits no longer have any stimulative effect on the economy.
Comparing changes in budget deficits to changes in interest rates is not a valid
way to determine whether budget deficits affect interest rates. That is because there
are many other factors that also affect interest rates. To determine the effect of
budget deficits on interest rates, one must hold these other factors constant using
statistical methods. Otherwise, the effect of budget deficits on interest rates could
be misestimated or even reversed.
Empirical evidence on a link between budget deficits and interest rates is mixed.
There is not a consensus among economists on how to model the economy and what
relevant variables should be included. Therefore, conclusions drawn from empirical
evidence vary widely. More recent evidence tends to find a stronger, positive
relationship between the two. In addition, 10 major forecasting models all predict
that a budget deficit would increase interest rates. According to Gale and Orszag
(2002), the models predict that a budget deficit equal to 1% of GDP would increase
interest rates, with a range of 0.1-1 (mean=0.52) percentage points after one year and
0.05-2 (mean=0.99) percentage points after 10 years. This report will not be updated.
Here’s what’s next.
This report can be searched. Note: Results may vary based on the legibility of text within the document.
Tools / Downloads
Get a copy of this page or view the extracted text.
Citing and Sharing
Basic information for referencing this web page. We also provide extended guidance on usage rights, references, copying or embedding.
Reference the current page of this Report.
Do Budget Deficits Push Up Interest Rates and Is This the Relevant Question?, report, May 13, 2003; Washington D.C.. (digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc808873/m1/2/: accessed July 21, 2018), University of North Texas Libraries, Digital Library, digital.library.unt.edu; crediting UNT Libraries Government Documents Department.