Effects of Light Scalar Mesons in eta -> 3pi decay Page: 2 of 17
This article is part of the collection entitled: Office of Scientific & Technical Information Technical Reports and was provided to Digital Library by the UNT Libraries Government Documents Department.
The following text was automatically extracted from the image on this page using optical character recognition software:
proposed new effects. Doubts about whether an unreasonably large value was assumed in  were expressed in .
These doubts were confirmed  using the work of the present paper. Still another reason for the interest in the
effects of the scalars in r7 -+ 37 is to provide an orientation for the discussion of the apparently puzzling r' -* 3 decays
in which light scalar mesons can be reasonably expected to have very large effects. We will give only a preliminary
discussion of this process here.
In section II we give a brief historical outline of treatments of ri - 37 decay based on chiral symmetry. A number
of well known ambiguities in the analysis are briefly described.
Our calculation is based on the tree level treatment of a chiral Lagrangian containing pseudoscalars, vectors and a
postulated nonet of light scalars. Since the calculation is somewhat complicated, it seems to us helpful to present the
results in a series of steps. First, in section III we give the results of using a Lagrangian containing only pseudoscalars
with minimal symmetry breaking terms.
To this Lagrangian we add, in section IV, the scalar mesons. It will be seen that the individual scalar diagrams
are quite large but there is a lot of cancellation so that the net effect is not at all dominant. However the scalars
do, as desired, increase the predicted decay rate in a noticeable way. Next, the effect of adding some derivative type
symmetry breakers for the pseudoscalars is described in section V. This doesn't much change the overall rate but
modifies the somewhat delicate cancellations so that the scalars end up making a larger percentage contribution than
before. In low energy calculations of this sort one always may expect some contributions from the vector mesons.
This is discussed in section VI where it is shown that, although there is a new type of diagram the vectors do not
produce a big change in the previous results.
Section VII contains a discussion of the results and directions for further work. For the convenience of readers,
material describing the chiral Lagrangian used is brought together in Appendix A. Similarly the detailed expression
for the decay amplitude is given in Appendix B.
II. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND ON THE r 4 37r DECAY
The study of ? - 3w has turned out to be surprisingly complicated and correspondingly important for understanding
the non-perturbative (low energy) structure of QCD. Chiral dynamics in various forms has been the basic tool. Since
the process violates G-parity it was initially assumed to be of electromagnetic nature, mediated by an effective photon
exchange operator proportional to the product of two electromagnetic currents. The old "current algebra" approach
had previously predicted the KL - w+,-o spectrum shape  to be
1 - 2E (1)
where m is the KL mass and Eo the energy of the 70 in the KL rest frame. This shape, which is in reasonable
agreement with experiment, resulted from the vanishing commutator of the axial charge transforming like a n+ with
the appropriate product of two weak currents. When Sutherland  repeated this type of calculation for ij -+ w+lr-hrO
with the product of two electromagnetic currents he found that the decay amplitude was actually zero (to this leading
order). Thus the sj -4 3w decay did not seem to be mediated by a virtual photon emission and reabsorption. In fact,
it was found  that a quark scalar density operator with the -XI = 1 property proportional to
fu - dd (2)
would give a non-zero result for the decay rate. A more detailed treatment  showed that the quark density operator
gave the same spectrum for rj -* +7-rO as in Eq.(1) with m the ij mass in this case. Such a result is in fairly good
agreement with experiment. The scalar density interaction in Eq.(2) was recognized  to be the fundamental
up-down quark mass difference generated by the Higgs meson in the electroweak theory.
However, the predicted rates of the 77 -+ 7+7--O and T/ -* 3w0 modes (both the ratios and the absolute values)
did not agree well with experiment at that time. Some years later, after more precise experiments, the ratio of the
rates for w+-7O to 3w0 modes stabilized around the value expected from isospin invariance. On the other hand the
absolute rate has only recently stabilized to a value notably larger than that predicted by theory. The theory behind
the current algebra results could be economically presented in the framework of an effective chiral Lagrangian. For
most low energy processes where the scheme could be expected to work, the tree level computation did produce results
within 25 % or so of experiment. Thus the relatively poor prediction for r) -+ 3w at tree level is somewhat surprising.
An improvement was obtained by Gasser and Leutwyler  who carried the computation of the chiral Lagrangian
amplitude to one loop level. Since the non-linear chiral Lagrangian is non-renormalizable, this required the addition
of new counterterms. Their finite parts were new parameters which could be mostly determined from other processes.
They obtained the result F(77 -+ +r- ) = 160 + 50 eV which may be compared with the present experimental
Here’s what’s next.
This article can be searched. Note: Results may vary based on the legibility of text within the document.
Tools / Downloads
Get a copy of this page or view the extracted text.
Citing and Sharing
Basic information for referencing this web page. We also provide extended guidance on usage rights, references, copying or embedding.
Reference the current page of this Article.
Abdel-Rehim, Abdou; Black, Deirdre; Fariborz, Amir H. & Schechter, Joseph. Effects of Light Scalar Mesons in eta -> 3pi decay, article, October 1, 2002; Newport News, Virginia. (digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc741604/m1/2/: accessed January 18, 2019), University of North Texas Libraries, Digital Library, digital.library.unt.edu; crediting UNT Libraries Government Documents Department.